Maybe you can fiddle around with both these lipsticks, suggested by Miss L & Q~Girl, they're both good choices and you can make the lips look natural with these.
Also in combination, using the opacity slider for the lipstick. You can minimize the 'gloss effect', but still be able to make the lips look natural.
Even when you set the opacity slider to minimum, there's still a difference between lips with or lips without lipstick.